Sunday, December 7, 2014

Is going to HR on an issue the Kiss of Death?


You are having an issue with your supervisor, a fellow employee, or you have been investigated by the Human resources department and have been written up...what do you do? This is a complex problem because the general consensus is that by filing a complaint you will opening Pandora’s box. To be honest, in many instances, that bad feeling you are experiencing is probably correct. There is no leader, employee, or HR for that matter that wants you to escalate an issue. This is especially true when the company that you work for uses an external complaint line. However, what is happening to you is not fare and it has risen to a point that it is impacting your job performance. If you stay in your present state, and you have been cited for performance, by not taking action there is a good chance you will adding insult to injury. If the issue is with your supervisor, there is the chance of retaliation...There is no doubt the whole mess is quite complicated.

Here are some suggestions to consider before taking action:

1.     Issue with supervisor: In this instance, consider scheduling a one-on-one to discuss the issues that you are having with him or her. However, if this is a matter of sexual harassment, I am sorry but you have no option than to report the issue to human Resources. In contrast, if the issues are job related, there are many instances where people do not realize that they are causing you stress and if handled properly, you may be able to work through the conflict. It is critical that you do not place blame and this is done by using “I feel” statements. For example, “I feel that I am being blamed for the production issue when in reality, I was not part of that project.” Also, it is critical to know your facts, presenting proof that the issue exists affirms that the issue has to be addressed. However, be for warned that that if the issue does resides with the supervisor you may find the conversation and the manger’s temperament changing from open to closed but if the issues are bothering you that much, it is a risk that you have to make.

2.     Issue with a co-worker: This is an interesting because there is nothing worse than truly enjoying your job only to have these feelings shadowed by a co-worker that for some reason has a problem with you. In some instances, the behavior is driven because you may be producing a higher quality of work than the  person, the person feels that something you did have caused a performance issue for the team, there are feelings of favoritism, or the person is simply a bully. The last point is important because workplace bullying is on the rise. The workplace bully is the same person that terrorized others when he or she was young. There are reasons why people bully and in almost all instances, what you are experiencing has nothing to do with you but issues the person is bringing to work with him or her every day. Maybe it is a failed marriage or money issues. It could also be a recent death in the family or just about any reason that is driving this person to take his or her frustrations out on you and maybe others. So how do you handle it? The first piece of advice I can share is that it is critical that you try to open a dialog with the person. The reason for this, is that if you escalate the issue to the manager or HR, they have to take action. If by chance the issue does not exist then, you not only have a problem with the person, you are now in the sights of those that can write you up or if they feel you did a higher level of damage to the person’s reputation, you could be terminated. If the issue is real, your next step must be the immediate supervisor to report the problem. If you bypass the manager and directly to HR, the manager will take it personally because his or her immediate supervisor may question the manager’s ability to lead so it you didn’t have an issue with the manager before, you will more than likely have one now.  

3.     What if you get a formal write-up?: In some cases a write-up is wrongfully administered or, it may be just but there are circumstances that have not been brought to light about the issue. In any instance, you have to sign it however; if you feel it is unjust you may write on the form “signed under duress.” Also, it is critical that whatever is said to you verbally, must be on the document. When a write-up is not on the up-and-up HR professionals will only put on the document what aligns with the law. There are many times where you may have made an improper judgment call but it did not violate company policy but because someone lost face, they may want to hold you accountable for something that should escalate to nothing more than a counseling dialog. If you feel that the document automatically has led to termination such as the case when theft is involved, you should immediately contact a labor attorney. The important aspect here is that if you did in fact steal something the only advise I can give you is to thank the employer for the opportunity and learn by the mistake. You do not want to be in a position where you swear you stole nothing when in fact you did. Also, it is essential that you rebut a formal write-up. There are many instances that those who are handling the issue (HR) do not have all of the details and a rebuttal maybe your only opportunity to have your voice heard and if termination is a possibility, you response to the allegations may be the only thing that could save your job. However, here is your reality check. In almost all instances, because the investigation against you was conducted by the HR investigator, very few decisions against someone are reversed. To these ends, if your organization has an external channel to have completed investigations reviewed, this is an option you may want to consider. I will not lie to you when I say, this will open a can of worms that may find people being creative with the truth in order not to get muddied by the situation.

A Story: I have a client that was accused of not addressing a situation concerning fraternization between two people in the same work team. In reality, because neither reported to another and the vagueness of the companies policy did not address such close working relationships neither my client nor his immediate supervisors consider a breach of policy existed. The couple considered to date and at the point where an engagement was announced, all of a sudden what wasn’t a problem became a problem. Considering the legal ramifications because an external client was connected to these two people, the issue then when as they put it “RED LIGHT.” The result of the lack of action was my client was set up to take the fall for her immediate leader’s lack of action. Furthermore, two other senior leaders were also aware of what was happening and did nothing. He received a write-up after my client brought it HR attention. It is obvious that the write up was instigated by one of the HR leaders who would be held accountable if the matter became legal. The saving grace for my client was that upon presenting the rebuttal, he made it very clear he was going to go to the companies external investigation team as well as the senior leader of the enterprise. The HR team as well as the manager that was responsible for putting her name on the write-up began to back-peddle. You see these are interesting circumstances because they could not prevent him from going external nor were they willing to withdraw the write-up because they would not admit there was something inappropriate that took place. Because this issue is not yet fully resolved, my client has not made a final decision if he will move forward with the external investigation do to the fact that his company is going through a re-structure and by filing the external complaint, he may be setting himself up for termination because all the company has to do is claim that the re-structure left one than one person without any further opportunity with the company.

Something to consider: the time to fight a bad write-up is right after it happens. However, you have to weigh what you have been charged with to the value of the job. If you conclude that the write-up will not have an impact on your future with the company you may want to consider taking it on the chin and consider it a learning experience. If the charged that have been brought against you and your reputation is going to be affected by the write-up staying in place, then you should fight. However, please understand that the moment you begin to stir the pot, there is a good change of additional ramifications landing at you’re from door.


Dr. Spencer L. Gaines offers in person coaching in the greater Jacksonville, Florida area as well virtual, phone, and chat coaching - simply click on this link "Click Here to Speak to Dr. Gaines Now" atWWW.IMotivateU.com. You are more than welcome to email me at IMotivateU@Att.net.